Start with the same operating assumptions
Give both vendors the same active truck, user and load counts, plus the monthly document volume and integrations you expect. Ask for the plan name, included limits and overage rates in writing. For per-load or per-document charges, multiply the billable volume above the included limit by the unit price before entering it below.
Worked example with illustrative prices
Quote A costs USD 200 per month, plus USD 75 for automation, USD 25 in estimated monthly usage and USD 500 for setup. The first-year estimate is 12 × (200 + 75 + 25) + 500 = USD 4,100.
Quote B costs USD 270 per month with automation included, the same USD 25 in estimated monthly usage and USD 300 for setup. The first-year estimate is 12 × (270 + 0 + 25) + 300 = USD 3,840. Quote B has the higher base price and costs USD 260 less in year one under these assumptions.
Ask vendors what the base license covers
- Workflow automation. Show a real rate confirmation or order coming in, how a draft load is created and who reviews incomplete or duplicate entries. Ask which step requires a paid module or configuration.
- Usage and integrations. Get the included counts for trucks, users, loads, documents and API calls. Ask what triggers a higher tier, and who bills for accounting, ELD or customer-system connections.
- Onboarding and support. Confirm fees for migration, training and setup. Ask which support hours and response times come with the plan.
- Renewal. Check the minimum term, year-two rates and export options. This worksheet estimates year one, so record renewal terms separately.
Can I compare a flat plan with a per-load quote?
Yes. Estimate the per-load bill at the same monthly volume and enter it as an estimated monthly usage charge. If there is a minimum, include any portion your estimate does not already cover. Run the worksheet again at your busiest expected volume to see whether the ranking changes.
How does Hawk Lane price workflow automation?
Hawk Lane quotes advanced workflow automation separately. See Hawk Lane TMS software pricing for Carrier TMS plan features, limits and separately scoped work. For features, onboarding and fleet fit, use the small-carrier TMS evaluation guide.